高原气象

高原气象 >

2016 , Vol. 35 >Issue 4: 1087 - 1101

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2015.00022

论文

三维变分方法反演风场的效果检验

  • 王艳春 ,
  • 王红艳 ,
  • 刘黎平
展开
  • 中国气象科学研究院, 北京 100081;2. 天津市气象台, 天津 300074

收稿日期: 2014-07-25

  网络出版日期: 2016-08-28

基金资助

中国气象局预报与网络司新技术集成推广专项（CMAGJ2013ZX-ZH1）；国家科技支撑计划项目（2012BAC22B00）；中国气象科学研究院基本科研业务费（2011Y003）；公益性行业（气象）科研专项（GYHY201406002）

收起

Performance Evaluation of Three-Dimensional Variation Assimilation Retrieval of Wind Field

  • WANG Yanchun ,
  • WANG Hongyan ,
  • LIU Liping
Expand
  • Chinese Academy of Meteorological Science, Beijing 100081, China;2. Tianjin Meteorological Observatory, Tianjin 300074, China

Received date: 2014-07-25

  Online published: 2016-08-28

Fold

摘要

为研究三维变分方法反演风场的能力、在不同天气系统中的适用性以及在实际业务工作中的应用潜力，利用广州、深圳、海口、湛江、龙岩和厦门六部多普勒天气雷达构成三个双多普勒雷达系统，选取热带风暴、飑线和层状云降水三种不同类型的天气过程。以双多普勒雷达反演的风场为“真值”，对风场三维结构进行了对比分析，并根据绝对误差、均方根误差和相关系数进行了定量的效果检验。结果表明，使用双雷达资料进行三维变分方法反演获得的风场结构与各类型天气的基本特征一致，能够较好地反演出飑线系统低层强对流区前缘阵风锋处的风场辐合以及热带风暴的气旋式环流。基于单部雷达资料和双雷达资料得到三维变分风场对比表明，使用单部雷达资料不能很好地表现强天气过程中的风场结构，对热带风暴的涡旋结构和飑线系统内部的辐合线结构的反演效果都较差，只有在风向沿雷达径向时才能得到较准确的风场结构；同时使用两部雷达资料进行风场反演，不仅降低了水平风向的反演误差，而且解决了单雷达反演风场时，雷达径向风分量反演结果较好、切向风分量反演结果较差的问题。误差分析结果表明水平风速和水平风向的反演结果都比较可靠，层状云降水的风场反演效果优于热带风暴和飑线系统的风场反演效果。

关键词： 多普勒雷达; 三维变分; 风场反演; 效果检验

本文引用格式

王艳春 , 王红艳 , 刘黎平 . 三维变分方法反演风场的效果检验[J]. 高原气象, 2016 , 35(4) : 1087 -1101 . DOI: 10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2015.00022

Abstract

In order to study the capacity, the applicability in different weather systems and the potential applications in business work of 3DVAR, three dual-Doppler radar systems corresponding three different weather systems as tropical storms, squall line and stratiform cloud precipitationare built by 6 Doppler weather radars which are Guangzhou radar, Shenzhen radar, Haikou radar, Zhanjiang radar, Longyan radar and Xiamen radar. The wind structure retrieved from dual-Doppler radar is used as ‘the true value’ to evaluate the performance of 3DVAR from the wind structure, AE, RMSE and COR. The results show that the wind structures retrieved from 3DVAR while using two radars dovetail nicely with the basic characteristics of various types of weather and could reproduce the convergence line in the low levels in a squall line and cyclonic circulation in a tropical storm. By comparing the wind retrieved from 3DVAR using single radar's data and that using two radars' data, it is indicated that While using one radar, it could not show wind structures of severe weather systems well and the retrieval performance of convergence line in the squall line and cyclonic circulation in the tropical storm is both poor. It could not only greatly reduce the error of wind direction but also improve the quality of tangential wind while using two radars' data. The results of error analysis indicate that the retrieval performance of wind speed and wind direction is reliable. The retrieval performance of stratiform clouds precipitation is superior to that of squall line and tropical storm.

Key words： Doppler radar; 3DVAR; Wind field retrieval; Performance evaluati

参考文献

[1]Armijo L.1969.A theory for the determination of wind and precipitation velocities with Doppler radar[J].J Atmos Sci, 26(3):570-573.
[2]Atlas D, Naito K, Corbone R E.1968.Bistatic microwave probing of a refractively perturbed clear atmosphere[J].J Atmos Sci, 25(2):257-268.
[3]Browning K A, Wexler R.1968.The determination of kinematic properties of a wind field using Doppler radar[J].J Appl Meteor, 7(1):105-113.
[4]Caton P G.1963.The measurement of wind and convergence by Doppler radar[C].Preprints:20th Weather Radar Conference, Amer Meteor Soc, 290-296.
[5]Chong M, Amayenc P, Scialom G, et al.1987.A Tropical squall line observed during the COPT 81 experiment in West Africa.Part Ⅰ:Kinematic structure inferred from dual-Doppler radar data[J].Mon Wea Rev, 115(3):670-694.
[6]Fankhauser J C, Barnes G M, Lemone M A.1992.Structure of a midlatitude squall line formed in strong unidirectional shear[J].Mon Wea Rev, 120(2):237-260.
[7]Kosciely A J, Doviak R J, Rabin R.1982.Statistical considerations in the estimation of divergence from single-Doppler radar and application to prestorm boundary-layer observations[J].J Appl Meteor, 21(2):197-210.
[8]Lhermitte R M, Atlas D.1961.Precipitation motion by pulse Doppler[C].American:9<sup>th</sup> Weather Radar Conference, Amer Meteor Soc, 218-223.
[9]Lhermitte R M, Miller L J.1970.Doppler radar methodology for the observation of convective storms[C].Preprints:14<sup>th</sup> Radar Meteor Conference, Amer Meteor Soc, 133-138.
[10]Li Nan, Wei Ming, Tang Xiaowen, et al.2007.An improved velocity volume processing method[J].Adv Atmos Sci, 24(5):893-906.
[11]Protat A, Isztar Z.1999.A variational method real-time retrieval of three-dimensional wind field from multiple-Doppler bistatic radar network data[J].J Atmos Oceanic Tech, 16(4):432-449.
[12]Qiu C J, Shao A M, Liu S, et al.2006.A two-step variational method for three-dimensional wind retrieval from single Doppler radar[J].Meteor Atmos Phys, 91(1):1-8.
[13]Shao A, Qiu C, Liu L.2004.Kinematic structure of a heavy rain event from dual-Doppler radar observations[J].Adv Atmos Sci, 21(4):609-616.
[14]Smull B F, Houze R A.1987.Dual-Doppler radar analysis of a midlatitude squall line with a trailing region of stratiform rain[J].J Atmos Sci, 44(15):2128-2149.
[15]Sun J, Crook A.1997a.Dynamical and microphysical retrieval from Doppler radar observations using a cloud model and its adjoint.Part I:Model development and simulate data experiments[J].J Atmos Sci, 54(12):1642-1661.
[16]Sun J, Crook A.1997b.Dynamical and microphysical retrieval from Doppler radar observations using a cloud model and its adjoint.Part II:Retrieval experiments of an observed Florida convective storm[J].J Atmos Sci, 55(5):835-852.
[17]Sun J, Zhang Y.2008.Analysis and prediction of a squall line observed during IHOP using multiple WSR-88D observations[J].Mon Wea Rev, 136(7):2364-2388.
[18]Tuttle J D, Foote J B.1990.Determination of the boundary layer airflow from a single Doppler radar[J].J Atmos Ocean Technol, 7(2):218-232.
[19]Waldteufel P, Corbin H.1979.On the analysis of single-doppler radar data[J].J Appl Meteor, 18(4):532-542.
[20]Wang T C C, Lin Y K, Shen H, et al.1990.Characteristics of a subtropical squall line determined from TAMEX dual-Doppler data.Part I:Kinematic structure[J].J Atmos Sci, 47(20):2357-2381.
[21]Wilson J W, Weckwerth T M, Vivekanandan J, et al.1994.Boundary layer clear-air radar echoes: Origin of echoes and accuracy of derived winds[J].J Atmos Oceanic Tech, 11(5):1184-1206.
[22]Xu Q, Qiu C J, Yu J X.1994.Adjoint-method retrievals of low-altitude wind fields from single-Doppler reflectivity measured during phoenix II[J].J Atmos Ocean Technol, 11(2):275-288.
[23]蔡淼, 周毓荃, 欧建军, 等.2015.三维云场分布诊断方法的研究[J].高原气象, 34(5):1330-1344.Cai Miao, Zhou Yuquan, Ou Jianjun, et al.2015.Study on diagnosing three dimensional cloud region[J].Plateau Meteor, 34(5):1330-1344.DOI:10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2014.00061.
[24]陈明轩, 王迎春, 高峰, 等.2011.基于雷达资料4DVar的低层热动力反演系统及其在北京奥运期间的初步应用分析[J].气象学报, 69(1):64-78.Chen Mingxuan, Wang Yingchun, Gao Feng, et al.2011.A low-level thermo-dynamical retrieval system based on the radar data 4DVar and a preliminary analysis of its applications in support of the Beijing 2008 Olympics[J].Acta Meteor Sinica, 69(1):64-78.
[25]丁伟钰, 万齐林, 端义宏.2005.TRMM降水率资料的三维变分同化及其对"杜鹃"(0313)台风预报的改进[J].大气科学, 29(4):601-608.Ding Weiyu, Wan Qilin, Duan Yihong.2005.3D-VAR assimilation of TRMM rain rate and its impact on the typhoon‘dujuan’(0313) forecast[J].Chinese J Atmos Sci, 29(4):601-608.
[26]段云霞, 李得勤.2012.台风"碧利斯"的雷达反演与改进[J].气象与环境学报, 28(5):25-33.Duan Yunxia, Li Deqin.2012.An analysis of wind field retrieval for typhoon‘Bilis’based on Doppler radar data and its improvement[J].J Meteor Environ, 28(5):25-33.
[27]郭凤霞, 王昊亮, 孙京, 等.2015.积云模式下三维闪电分形结构的数值模拟[J].高原气象, 34(2):534-545.Guo Fengxia, Wang Haoliang, Sun Jing, et al.2015.Simulation of three-dimensional fractal structure of lightning in a thunderstorm model[J].Plateau Meteor, 34(2):534-545.DOI:10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2013.00193.
[28]姜海燕, 葛润生.1997.一种新的单部多普勒雷达反演技术[J].应用气象学报, 8(2):219-223.Jiang Haiyan, Ge Runsheng.1997.A new retrieval technique for single Doppler radar[J].J Appl Meteor Sci, 8(2):219-223.
[29]李华宏, 曹杰, 杞明辉, 等.2012.雷达风廓线反演在云南强降水预报中的应用[J].高原气象, 31(6):1739-1745.Li Honghua, Cao Jie, Qi Minghui, et al.2012.Application of vertical wind profile from Doppler radar to the forecast of heavy precipitation in Yunnan[J].Plateau Meteor, 31(6):1739-1745.
[30]李江南, 王安宇, 杨兆礼, 等.2003.用QuikSCAT资料分析"黄蜂"登陆前后近地层风场的分布特征[J].热带气象学报, 19(1):88-99.Li Jiangnan, Wang Anyu, Yang Zhaoli, et al.2003.Features of the surface wind distribution of typhoon ‘huangfeng’landfall process based on QuikSCAT data[J].J Trop Meteor, 19(1):88-99.
[31]李青青, 周立, 范轶.2009.台风云娜(2004)的高分辨率数值模拟研究:眼壁小尺度对流运动[J].气象学报, 67(5):787-798.Li Qingqing, Zhou Li, Fan Yi.2009.A high-resolution numerical simulation of typhoon rananim (2004):Small-scale convection in the eyewal[J].Acta Meteor Sinica, 67(5):787-798.
[32]刘黎平, 莫月琴, 沙雪松, 等.2005.C波段双多基地多普勒雷达资料处理和三维变分风场反演方法研究[J].大气科学, 29(6):986-996.Liu Liping, Mo Yueqin, Sha Xuesong, et al.2005.Radar data processing and a variational algorithm for 3-dimensional wind field retrieval by C band bistatic radar network[J].Chinese J Atmos Sci, 29(6):986-996.
[33]刘黎平, 张沛源, 梁海河, 等.2003.双多普勒雷达风场反演误差和资料的质量控制[J].应用气象学报, 14(1):17-29.Liu Liping, Zhang Peiyuan, Liang Haihe, et al.2003.Error estimation in wind fields derived from dual-Doppler radar and data quality control[J].J Appl Meteor Sci, 14(1):17-29.
[34]刘黎平.2003.用双多普勒雷达反演降水系统三为风场试验研究[J].应用气象学报, 14(4):502-508.Liu Liping.2003.The study of 3-D wind derived from dual-Doppler radar[J].J Appl Meteor Sci, 14(4):502-508.
[35]罗昌荣, 池艳珍, 周海光.2012.双雷达反演台风外围强带状回波风场结构特征研究[J].大气科学, 36(2):247-258.Luo Changrong, Chi Yanzhen, Zhou Haiguang.2012.Characteristics of 3-D wind structure of typhoon outer intensive banded echo using dual-Doppler weather radar data[J].Chinese J Atmos Sci, 36(2):247-258.
[36]裴宇杰, 王福侠, 张迎新, 等.2012.2009年晚秋河北特大暴雪多普勒雷达特征分析[J].高原气象, 31(4):1110-1118.Pei Yujie, Wang Fuxia, Zhang Yingxin, et al.2012.Analysis on Doppler radar feature of snowstorm in Hebei in late autumn of 2009[J].Plateau Meteor, 31(4):1110-1118.
[37]邱崇践, Qin Xu.1996.由单Doppler雷达资料反演水平风场的简单共轭函数方法的改进方案[J].应用气象学报, 7(4):421-430.Qiu Chongjian, Qin Xu.1996.An improvement on the simple coniugate method for retrieving the wind fields from single-Doppler data[J].J Appl Meteor Sci, 7(4):421-430.
[38]陶祖钰, 田佰军, 黄伟.1994.9216号台风登陆后的不对称结构和暴雨[J].热带气象学报, 10(1):69-77.Tao Zuyu, Tian Baijun, Huang Wei.1994.Asymmetry structure and torrential rain of landing typhoon 9216[J].J Trop Meteor, 10(1):69-77.
[39]陶祖钰.1992.从单Doppler速度场反演风矢量场的VAP方法[J].气象学报, 50(1):81-90.Tao Zuyu.1992.The vap method to retrieve the wind vector field based on single-Doppler velocity field[J].Acta Meteor Sinica, 50(1):81-90.
[40]王俊, 盛日锋, 陈西利.2011.一次弓状回波、强对流风暴及合并过程研究Ⅱ:双多普勒雷达三维风场分析[J].高原气象, 30(4):1078-1086.Wang Jun, Sheng Rifeng, Chen Xili.2011.Case study of bow echo, severe convective storm and merger process Ⅱ:Analysis on three-dimensional wind field retrieved by dual Doppler radar[J].Plateau Meteor, 30(4):1078-1086.
[41]肖艳娇, 万玉发, 王珏, 等.2012.一种自动多普勒雷达速度退模糊算法研究[J].高原气象, 31(4):1119-1128.Xiao Yanjiao, Wan Yufa, Wang Jue, et al.2012.Study of an automated Doppler radar velocity dealiasing algorithm[J].Plateau Meteor, 31(4):1119-1128.
[42]杨毅, 邱崇践, 龚建东, 等.2008.利用3维变分方法同化多普勒天气雷达资料的试验研究[J].气象科学, 28(2):124-132.Yang Yi, Qiu Chongjian, Gong Jiandong, et al.2008.Study on Doppler weather radar data assimilation via 3d-var[J].Scientia Meteor Sinica, 28(2):124-132.
[43]张勇, 刘黎平, 仰美霖, 等.2011."天鹅"台风风场结构特征[J].气象, 37(6):659-669.Zhang Yong, Liu Liping, Yang Meilin, et al.2011.Analysis on the structure characteristics of Typhoon ‘Goni’[J].Meteor Mon, 37(6):659-669.
[44]赵娟, 王斌, 刘娟娟.2012.预分析初始扰动样本对降维投影四维变分同化性能的影响[J].气象学报, 70(3):549-561.Zhao Juan, Wang Bin, Liu Juanjuan.2012.Influence of pre-analyzing the initial perturbation sample on DRP-4DVar assimilation performance[J].Acta Meteor Sinica, 70(3):549-561.
[45]周海光, 王玉彬.2002.多部多普勒雷达同步探测三维风场反演系统[J].气象, 28(9):7-11.Zhou Haiguang, Wang Yubin.2002.A retrieving system of three-dimensional wind fields by multiple-Doppler radar[J].Meteor Mon, 28(9):7-11.
[46]朱立娟, 龚建东, 李泽椿.2012.资料同化中雷达VAD风质量控制研究[J].高原气象, 31(6):1731-1738.Zhu Lijuan, Gong Jiandong, Li Zechun.2012.Study on quality control of radar VAD wind in data assimilation[J].Plateau Meteor, 31(6):1731-1738.
[47]朱乾根, 林锦瑞, 寿绍文, 等.2010.天气学原理和方法[M].北京:气象出版社, 514.Zhu Qiangen, Lin Jinrui, Shou Shaowen, et al.2010.Synoptic Meteorology[M].Beijing:China Meteorological Press, 514.
Options
文章导航

/

〈 〉

本系统由北京玛格泰克科技发展有限公司设计开发 技术支持：support@magtech.com.cn